In-Ground Dog Fence Reviews for 2017
There are 3 main concerns that keep dog owners up at night. First, how so I keep my dog safe? Second, how do I keep my dog in great shape? Third, how is this possible without spending more time and money than I am willing to?
The in-ground dog fence provides an opportunity to address all three problems. When trained correctly, the best in-ground dog fence can prevent your dog from running away or into danger’s path. When it comes to comparing the best in-ground dog fences on the market, there are many options to consider. Using the Quality Dog Fence rating system, we have conveniently broken down what you need to know in this comprehensive, easy to read chart.
Best In-Ground Dog Fences for 2017
|Features||Innotek® Basic In-ground Pet Fencing System, SD-2000||Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence||PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence|
|Quality Review||Quality Review on the Innotek® Basic In-ground Pet Fencing System, SD-2000||Quality Review on the Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence||Quality Review on the PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence|
|Range||500 feet, area ⅓ acre||500-5000 feet, area ⅓ to 25 acres||500-5000 feet, area ⅓ to 25 acres|
|Expandable Boundary||No||Yes, not past 5000 feet||Yes, not past 5000 feet|
|Number of Dogs Supported||Unlimited||Unlimited||Unlimited|
|Dog Weight Range||10 pounds and up||5 pounds and up||20 pounds and up|
|Collar Neck Size||8-21 inches||6-16 inches||6-28 inches|
|Correction Levels||1 tone-only, 1 level of static correction||1 tone-only, 4 levels of static correction||1 tone-only, 4 levels of static correction|
|Vibration Only Settings||No||No||Yes|
|Collar Batteries||Replaceable (last 1-3 months)||Replaceable (last 2-3 months)||Replaceable (last 3-4 months)|
|Water Resistance||Weatherproof||Weatherproof||100% Waterproof|
|Price||Check Current Amazon Pricing||Check Current Amazon Pricing||Check Current Amazon Pricing|
Why Should I Invest in an In-ground Dog Fence?
Problem #1: you need to keep your dog healthy and safe. Problem #2: you need to keep your flower beds and lawns healthy and safe. Problem #3: you can’t give up either dogs or plants. The good news? You don’t have to. Investing in an in-ground dog fence takes care of all three problems.
A dog without exercise is an unhappy dog. With little to stimulate him and too much energy to burn off in a quick walk, he might even become an aggressive or misbehaving dog. When a dog lies around the house without responding to invitations to play, he hasn’t become better-tempered–he is becoming lethargic from unhappiness.
The problem is, you can’t just let him out into the yard. He refuses to stay near the house, and dashes to the street every chance he gets. You can’t keep an eye on him either–a single glance to check the food on the stove and he’s off, chasing bicycles or other dogs on leashes. Even scarier, he’s on the street where there are a lot of vehicles much bigger than him.
Say you’ve found a community that will let you build a privacy fence. Your dog has all the space he could ask for and more. There’s just one problem: he’s a digger, and when he’s not digging a hole under the fence he’s in your flower beds, or burying toys in the lawn.
That or he’s a jumper, miraculously able to get over your fence. Or, worse, he’s one of those Houdini kinds who finds cracks where there are none and slips out the fence somehow. Not only is your dog no longer safe, even when he is contained inside you still have to watch to make sure he’s not anywhere he shouldn’t be.
You can fix both problems at the same time with the in-ground dog fence. Customizable in shape, enclosing large enough areas for the most active dog to play in, it is the ideal answer.
Why Go In-ground?
There are several features in which the wireless dog fence has the advantage, such as in terms of portability and set-up speed. However, the in-ground fence has the definite advantage in two aspects: the boundary blur, and the customizable area.
In-ground Fences Have No Boundary Blur Issues
Any invisible or electric dog fence depends on the connection between the signal transmitter and the receiver collar. For a wireless dog fence, the signal comes from the transmitter in radio waves or wifi form towards the receiver collar. When the dog gets too far away, the collar is alerted to issue the warning beep, and then the static correction if the dog keeps going.
The problem for the wireless dog fence is that “too far away” changes by the second, fluctuating from 3 to 10 feet, depending on the model. The in-ground fence has no problems with that at all. Because the collar knows of the boundary through the signal run through the boundary wire, there is never more than 0.5 feet of boundary blur, if any at all. The moment your dog knows his boundaries, he can play with perfect confidence anywhere near the warning lines (right before the need for a warning beep). This is the biggest advantage of the in-ground fence.
The In-ground Fence Has A Perfectly Customizable Area
Whether your yard is square, circle, or resembles a Picasso painting, the wireless dog fence will almost always be only in one shape: circular. The design of the fence, to make it portable and easy to set up, demands that simplicity.
The in-ground fence is perfectly customizable. You can even lay it out in a dog-shape if you want to. This feature allows you to lay it along a privacy fence, around flower beds and the swimming pool, and even in front of a garage or workshed. So whether you want to give your dog his own corner of the yard, or make your entire property his playground without having to worry about his getting out of your fence or into your garden, the in-ground fence is the perfect choice.
Those are the two main advantages to owning an in-ground fence. If those are exactly what you are looking for, then you definitely need the in-ground electric dog fence. Read on to find out more about how it can help you with your dog.
What Can I Expect From An In-ground Dog Fence?
All in-ground dog fence models have their unique attributes that fit them to different kinds of fencing needs. However, they have several pros and cons in common you should know about. If you are getting an in-ground dog fence, prepare to expect these features and challenges.
Pros of an In-ground Dog Fence
The most obvious pros are the negligent boundary blur and the customizable area. Another feature that most in-ground fences have is the progressive static correction feature. One of the biggest problems of dog owners who use electric dog fences is that when their dogs run through the boundary, they can sometimes be in such a state of excitement that the static correction ceases to engage their attention.
The progressive static correction feature compensates for that. The intensity of the static correction slowly increases the farther away the dog gets from the boundary line, to the point where it is enough to get his attention and surprise him out of bad behavior. When he returns to the boundary, the static correction ends at once. Like the static correction itself, it is a last-resort method: if the dog forgets that the static correction means “go back,” the progressive static correction reinforces the reminder.
Another desirable feature of the in-ground fence is that it has a widely expandable boundary. It always depends on how many feet of wire the signal transmitter can handle, but they can usually handle up to 5000 feet of wire, giving you a whole 25 acres for your dog to run around in. Since every foot of the 5000 is also customizable, it should more than meet your needs.
Cons of an In-ground Dog Fence
The in-ground fence, while invisible, is not portable. If you travel often, or travel for long periods of time to family homes, you’ll need to find another way of containing your dog that will still keep him happy, safe, and healthy. In fact, if you have those problems when it comes to travel, it might be better to kill two birds with one stone and get the wireless dog fence instead.
Another negative aspect of the in-ground fence is that it will take at least half-a-day to set up, on average. You need a whole free weekend to set it up, and that does not include the planning. Whether you bury it or staple it, laying it out exactly where you want takes a lot of concentration and time. Before that, you need to know where all your water pipes and underground wires are, if you are planning to bury your wire. You don’t want to hit anything important and be forced to pay more for repairs. Even stapling it down is difficult: you need to make sure that the wires are nowhere they can be easily damaged.
In-ground vis-á-vis Wireless Fences
Both of these of invisible and electric dog fences have specific attributes that are better or worse depending on what you need. Let us look at some of the pros and cons of the wireless fences compared to the in-ground, so you can see which one might be better suited to you and your dog.
Pros of the Wireless Dog Fence
The wireless fence was designed to be portable. It has a carry-around transmitter which can be set up anywhere with a power outlet. You can set it up on the road, or even at your family property, and when your dog’s receiver collar is on he will enjoy the same exercise and freedom he does at home.
The wireless fence is also very simple to set up: you’d rarely take more than 2 hours maximum, even after pacing out the boundary, setting up the training flags, and testing the receiver collar. Its transmitter is designed to be plug-and-play–simply plug it in and it’s operational.
The wireless fence also has an extremely flexible boundary. At a moment’s notice, you can tighten your dog’s playspace, or expand it. This is convenient if you travel often, so you can tighten the circle on the road, and expand it at the destination. You can also tighten the circle and place the transmitter in a farther part of the property to let your dog exercise while you have friends over, or a party going on.
Cons of the Wireless Dog Fence
The main challenge of the wireless fence is that the boundary blur is much higher and much less stable than that of the in-ground fence. The best models are the Havahart models, which have a minimum of 1.5 feet of boundary blur. However, this fluctuation demands rigid training of the dogs to respond to the warning beep rather than to their known boundaries, or else they may become upset and fearful because of the static correction.
Another challenge of the wireless fence is that there cannot be too many obstructions between the transmitter and the receiver collar. Anything large and metal such as a shed or a car will interrupt the signal altogether. For some models, trees and taller shrubs also constitute signal interrupters. Something as simple as bumpy ground can also interrupt the signal, for some models.
Best In-ground Dog Fence Review Summaries
The full product reviews are more detailed and tell you more about how to pick the perfect in-ground fence for your dog. These summaries only give you a nutshell of the unique features of each in-ground dog fence, and how they are best used.
The Innotek® SD-2000
The Innotek® SD-2000 is the best in-ground dog fence for the cheapest price. Although it only has one level of static correction, it also has a tone-only training option, and the level of static correction is progressive. This makes it ideal for the average dog. It accommodates dogs 10 pounds and up, covers up to 5 acres of playspace, can contain an unlimited number of dogs, and fits neck sizes between 8 and 21 inches. It runs on generic replaceable batteries that last an average of 2-3 months.
Check out the comprehensive The Innotek® SD-2000 review here.
The Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence
The Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence is custom-made for small dogs, who may respond negatively to the more generic ranges of static correction. The 4 levels of static correction are all on a lower intensity more suited to small dogs, and all are progressive. A tone-only mode is present for training. It is designed for dogs 5 pounds and heavier, and for neck sizes from 6 to 16 inches wide. It can contain an unlimited number of dogs in ⅓ to 25 acres of space. It uses replaceable batteries that last around 2-4 months, but rechargeable batteries can be used as well, although not as effectively.
Check out the comprehensive Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence review here.
The PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence
For large, stubborn dogs, dogs hard of hearing, or feisty little dogs who pay no attention when they’re onto something exciting, this model, the PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence, is ideal. It is designed with a tone-only setting and vibration-only setting for training, and also for dogs hard of hearing. There are 4 levels of static correction designed for stubborn dogs, all of them progressive to make sure your dog cannot ignore the warning, with a timeout after 30 seconds. It works on dogs 20-50 pounds and up, and fits 6- to 28-inch neck sizes. The fence can contain an unlimited number of dogs, within an area of ⅓ to 25 acres. It is powered by replaceable generic 9-volt batteries that can be picked up anywhere and last around 3-4 months.
Check out the comprehensive PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence review here.