Invisible and Electric Dog Fence Comparison

When shopping for the ideal dog fence, it is important to use an invisible or electric dog fence comparison guide to match up all the important information. A good comparison should consider whether or not the device is in-ground or wireless, should compare key factors like range and correction levels, and should consider the size of your dog. Below we have broken up best selling products by wireless and in-ground models, providing you an electric dog fence comparison by key features.

You will also find underneath the comparison charts short summaries of the products to help you determine if the product is right for you and your dog.

invisible-dog-fence-comparison

Comparison of Wireless Dog Fence vs In-ground Electric Dog Fence

Invisible and Electric Dog Fence Comparison Guide

When trained correctly, it can prevent your dog from running into the street and meeting an accident, or running after an animal or bicycle and getting lost. When it comes to comparing the best wireless dog fences on the market, there are many options to consider. Using the Quality Dog Fence rating system, we have conveniently broken down what you need to know in this comprehensive, easy to read chart. 

Best Wireless Dog Fences for 2017

FeaturesHavahart Radial-Shape Wireless Dog FenceHavahart Radial-Shape Wireless Dog Fence for Small DogsPerimeter Technologies Wire-Free WiFi Dog FencePetSafe® PIF-300 Wireless Dog Containment System
Product Imagewireless-dog-fenceHavahart Wireless Small DogPerimeter-Technologies-Wi-Fi-WirelessPetSafe-PIF-300-Review
Quality ReviewQuality Review of the Havahart Radial Wireless FenceQuality Review of the Havahart Radial Wireless Fence for Small DogsQuality Review of the Perimeter Technologies Wi-Fi FenceQuality Review of the PetSafe® PIF-300 Wireless Dog Fence
Quality RatingQDF 4 StarsQDF 4 StarsQDF 3 StarsQDF 4 Stars
RangeMaximum 400 feet from the transmitter in all directions, 800 feet in diameter; area up to 11 acres
Maximum 400 feet from the transmitter in all directions, 800 feet in diameter; area up to 11 acresMaximum 180 feet from the transmitter in all directions, 360 feet in diameter; area up to 2 ½ acresMaximum 90 feet from the transmitter in all directions, 180 feet in diameter; area ½ acre
Expandable BoundaryNoNoNoYes, with additional PIF-300 transmitters
Number of Dogs Supported222Unlimited
Dog Weight Range8 pounds and up8 pounds and up10 pounds and up8 pounds and up
Collar Neck Size14-26 inches12-17 inches14-26 inches6-28 inches
Correction Levels1 tone-only, 5 static correction levels1 tone-only, 5 static correction levels1 tone-only, 8 static correction levels1 tone-only, 4 static correction levels
Progressive CorrectionNoNoYesNo
Vibration Only SettingsNoNoNoNo
Collar BatteriesRechargeable (lasts 1-3 days)Rechargeable (lasts 1-3 days)Rechargeable (lasts 5-7 days)Replaceable (lasts 1-3 months)
Water ResistanceWeatherproofWeatherproof100% WaterproofWeatherproof
Back-up for TransmitterNoNoYes (lasts up to 8 hours)No
PriceCheck Current Amazon PricingCheck Current Amazon PricingCheck Current Amazon PricingCheck Current Amazon Pricing
Buy Now! 

Invisible and Electric Dog Fence Reviews

The PetSafe® Wireless Containment System PIF-300

The PetSafe® PIF-300 gives your dog 10-90 feet of play space in all directions, a maximum area of ½ acres. The gallon-can design of the transmitter makes it easy to bring along during travelling. This system works best with dogs over 8 lbs. in weight, and the collar can fit any neck size between 8 and 26 inches. It can contain an unlimited number of dogs, and the territory can be expanded by overlapping transmitter signals. Boundary blur is between 2 to 3 feet, and static correction runs for 30 seconds with 5-minute intervals until the dog is back in his boundary. Batteries are replaceable and last 1-3 months.

The Havahart Radial Wireless System

The Havahart Radial model gives your dog a radial range of 40-400 ft to play in–an area of 11 acres. It is designed to work best with dogs over 8 pounds in weight, and can accommodate dogs with 14-26 inch necks. It can contain up to 2 dogs. Boundary blur is the best, between 1 and 1 ½ feet. and the static correction is timed to stop after 30 seconds. Batteries last between 1 and 3 days and are recharged within 2-3 hours. The package comes with 2 battery packs.

compare-dog-fences

The Havahart Radial Wireless System for Small Dogs

Like the original Havahart System, this model has a maximum of 11 acres of play space. The Havahart Radial Wireless System for Small Dogs is designed for dogs over 8 pounds with a neck size between 12 and 17 inches, and contains up to 2 dogs. Boundary blur is classic Havahart quality with 1-1 ½ feet, and static correction lasts only up to 30 seconds. It runs on rechargeable batteries that should be checked every day but normally last 1-3 days.

The Perimeter Technologies WiFi Wireless Fence

The Perimeter Technologies model offers a medium-sized area of 2 ½ acres of running space. It is designed to be set on any flat surface or mounted on a wall. It’s made for dogs over 10-20 lbs. of weight, with neck sizes up to 26 inches, and can contain up to 2 dogs. Its best features are that it is 100% waterproof, and that it can be set high enough so that the signal reaches the dog even over shrubs or small plants and bumpy ground. However, its boundary blur is 10-20 feet, which is the feature that most devalues the model. As for the batteries, both the transmitter and the collar have rechargeable batteries. The transmitter battery lasts up to 8 hours when fully charged, and serves as a backup.

best--dog-fence-comparison-2015

Buying an In-ground Dog Fence

When trained correctly, the best in-ground dog fence can prevent your dog from running away or into danger’s path. When it comes to comparing the best in-ground dog fences on the market, there are many options to consider. Using the Quality Dog Fence rating system, we have conveniently broken down what you need to know in this comprehensive, easy to read chart.

Best In-Ground Dog Fences for 2017

FeaturesInnotek® Basic In-ground Pet Fencing System, SD-2000Elite Little Dog In-ground FencePetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence
Product ImageInnotek-invisible-fenceIn-Ground-invisible-dog-fencepetsafe-stubborn-dog-in-ground-fence-review
Quality ReviewQuality Review on the Innotek® Basic In-ground Pet Fencing System, SD-2000Quality Review on the Elite Little Dog In-ground FenceQuality Review on the PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence
Quality RatingQDF 4 StarsQDF 4 StarsQDF 3 Stars
Range500 feet, area ⅓ acre500-5000 feet, area ⅓ to 25 acres500-5000 feet, area ⅓ to 25 acres
Expandable BoundaryNoYes, not past 5000 feetYes, not past 5000 feet
Number of Dogs SupportedUnlimitedUnlimitedUnlimited
Dog Weight Range10 pounds and up5 pounds and up20 pounds and up
Collar Neck Size8-21 inches6-16 inches6-28 inches
Correction Levels1 tone-only, 1 level of static correction1 tone-only, 4 levels of static correction1 tone-only, 4 levels of static correction
Progressive CorrectionYesYesYes
Vibration Only SettingsNoNoYes
Collar BatteriesReplaceable (last 1-3 months)Replaceable (last 2-3 months)Replaceable (last 3-4 months)
Water ResistanceWeatherproofWeatherproof100% Waterproof
PriceCheck Current Amazon PricingCheck Current Amazon Pricing
Check Current Amazon Pricing
Buy Now!

Best In-ground Dog Fence Review Summaries

The full product reviews are more detailed and tell you more about how to pick the perfect in-ground fence for your dog. These summaries only give you a nutshell of the unique features of each in-ground dog fence, and how they are best used.

The Innotek® SD-2000

The Innotek® SD-2000 is the best in-ground dog fence for the cheapest price. Although it only has one level of static correction, it also has a tone-only training option, and the level of static correction is progressive. This makes it ideal for the average dog. It accommodates dogs 10 pounds and up, covers up to 5 acres of playspace, can contain an unlimited number of dogs, and fits neck sizes between 8 and 21 inches. It runs on generic replaceable batteries that last an average of 2-3 months.

Innotek-SD-2000

Check out the comprehensive The Innotek® SD-2000 review here.

The Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence

The Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence is custom-made for small dogs, who may respond negatively to the more generic ranges of static correction. The 4 levels of static correction are all on a lower intensity more suited to small dogs, and all are progressive. A tone-only mode is present for training. It is designed for dogs 5 pounds and heavier, and for neck sizes from 6 to 16 inches wide. It can contain an unlimited number of dogs in ⅓ to 25 acres of space. It uses replaceable batteries that last around 2-4 months, but rechargeable batteries can be used as well, although not as effectively.

Elite-Little-Dog-In-Ground-Fence

Check out the comprehensive Elite Little Dog In-ground Fence review here.

The PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence

For large, stubborn dogs, dogs hard of hearing, or feisty little dogs who pay no attention when they’re onto something exciting, this model, the PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence, is ideal. It is designed with a tone-only setting and vibration-only setting for training, and also for dogs hard of hearing. There are 4 levels of static correction designed for stubborn dogs, all of them progressive to make sure your dog cannot ignore the warning, with a timeout after 30 seconds. It works on dogs 20-50 pounds and up, and fits 6- to 28-inch neck sizes. The fence can contain an unlimited number of dogs, within an area of ⅓ to 25 acres. It is powered by replaceable generic 9-volt batteries that can be picked up anywhere and last around 3-4 months.

stubborn-dog-invisible-fence

Check out the comprehensive PetSafe® Stubborn Dog In-ground Fence review here.